YouTube, TikTok Claim Liberal Online Streaming Bill Will Harm Digital Creators – National

Online streaming giants YouTube and TikTok are calling on Canadian senators to soberly reconsider an online streaming bill they claim will seriously harm Canada’s digital creators.

TikTok executive Steve de Eyre told a Senate committee meeting Wednesday night that the Federal Liberal Party’s bill C-11 not only failed to protect digital creators from regulation, but also caused collateral damage. said it is giving

He said the Senate should more explicitly exclude user-generated content from bills aimed at modernizing Canada’s broadcasting laws and introducing online streaming platforms.

read more:

What legacy will Charles III bring to the British throne when he begins his reign?

The senator should also consider rules on how to identify Canadian content, he said, noting that much of the content created on TikTok by Canadians is not like that.

The story continues under the ad

That means “established media voices and cultural voices” with more resources could come to the forefront.Canadian Government Relations.

YouTube executive Jeanette Patell told senators the bill gives Canada’s broadcast regulators too much leeway to make demands on user-generated content.

She said the provision allowing regulators to consider whether someone is directly or indirectly monetizing their content affects “virtually everything” on the platform.

“This is a global precedent,” said Patell, YouTube’s head of government affairs and public policy.

Click to play video: 'Trudeau has not committed to releasing policy directives to the CRTC regarding online streaming laws'

Prime Minister Trudeau has not committed to release a policy directive to the CRTC on the Online Streaming Act.

Prime Minister Trudeau Doesn’t Commit to Release Policy Directive to CRTC on Online Streaming Law – May 11, 2022

She warned that if other countries followed suit, creators in Canada, where 90% of YouTube views come from abroad, would struggle to get noticed. is not in the world, and it really puts creators’ audiences around the world at risk.”

The story continues under the ad

Patel also warned that regulators could require changes to the company’s algorithm, echoing concerns music-streaming giant Spotify raised at a public hearing last week.

The scare is based on the testimony of Ian Scott, chairman of the Canadian Radio, Television and Telecommunications Commission.

Scott told senators in June that regulators could ask platforms like YouTube to “manipulate” algorithms to produce specific results.

At last week’s conference, Nathan Wiszniak, Spotify’s head of Canadian artist and label partnerships, said that influencing how the platform generates recommendations for individual listeners goes against its raison d’etre. It said it could generate negative feedback for the songs being distributed. Recommended.

“Ask a service to repeatedly bias recommendations against listeners’ tastes, and it takes a toll on the core trust we have built with our customers,” he said.

read more:

US fears Ottawa online streaming bill could affect trade with Canada

Some Quebec senators have refuted the idea that requiring algorithms to direct users to Canadian content is a very bad thing to do.

Senator Julie Miville Deshen said the bill would require companies to choose measures that make it easier for them to find Canadian artists. “Are there non-algorithmic avenues for promoting Canadian content?” she asked Patel. “Why are you scared?”

The story continues under the ad

Senator Renée Cormier recommends that algorithms listen to English-speaking music when he himself uses YouTube, named after Quebec artist Ariane Moffat, whom he has repeatedly dropped. I noticed that “I’m trying to understand why I can’t continue with the same type of music I already listen to,” he said. “Why are the recommendations directing me elsewhere?”

Patell said YouTube is about “you” and its users train algorithms to meet their needs. When Canadians come looking for Canadian content, she said, “We absolutely want to deliver it.”

Click to play video:

How Bill C-11 Will Change Canadian Streaming Services

How Bill C-11 Will Change Canadian Streaming Services – March 11, 2022

While de Eyre said TikTok “democratizes discoverability,” Ontario senator Bernadette Clement pointed out that “it’s not democratic if people don’t know how the algorithms work.” Patell and de Eyre responded that they make their source code and raw data available to researchers.

The story continues under the ad

Streaming companies recommend alleviating concerns by making specific adjustments to the bill’s language.

In June, before the Congressional summer break, the House of Representatives passed Bill C-11, which contains more than 150 amendments. Rather than hastening its passage, the Senate has decided to give it a more thorough consideration this fall.

If the Senate decides to amend the bill, it must be sent back to the House for approval before it becomes law.

© 2022 Canadian Press

YouTube, TikTok Claim Liberal Online Streaming Bill Will Harm Digital Creators – National

Source link YouTube, TikTok Claim Liberal Online Streaming Bill Will Harm Digital Creators – National

Related Articles

Back to top button